Howard Ding, Sales Manager

Request a quote

Casting porosity acceptance criteria

What porosity is acceptable depends on where it is and what the region does. Write the criterion per zone, with the method, reference standard, sampling and failure response, so supplier and buyer read the X-ray the same way.

What a porosity requirement must say

Specify the casting region, the discontinuities assessed, the inspection method, the acceptance criterion and the production stage it applies to. Add the sampling plan, the report and what happens after a failed result. A reference standard on its own, or a phrase such as "low porosity", does not complete the agreement: the requirement has to describe an inspection both parties can perform and read the same way.

  1. Region. A zone on the drawing or a zone map, with boundaries an inspector can find without asking the designer.
  2. Condition. As-cast, after heat treatment, after machining, or as supplied.
  3. Discontinuity. Gas porosity, shrinkage, inclusions; separate criteria where needed.
  4. Method and reference. Film or digital radiography, CT, sectioning; the reference standard, edition and level.
  5. Sampling. Lot definition, quantity or frequency, selection method.
  6. Evidence and response. Images or measurements, part ID, who interprets, and the disposition route.

Choose the reference for the actual examination

Reference radiographs help classify indications; they do not choose a suitable level for your part. ASTM describes E155 as a basis from which application-specific acceptance requirements can be developed. Do not convert a radiographic severity level into a pore diameter or area percentage without a separately justified, agreed measurement.

ExaminationReference to reviewScope question to resolve
Film radiography, aluminum castingsASTM E155Material, section thickness, discontinuity category
Digital radiography, aluminum castingsASTM E2422Suitability of the digital reference and the system
Film radiography, aluminum or magnesium die castingsASTM E505Die-casting reference, thickness range, category
Digital radiography, aluminum or magnesium die castingsASTM E2973Digital die-casting reference and examination attributes

These are references to evaluate, not four interchangeable choices. E505 directs digital die-casting examinations to E2973; E155 directs digital aluminum-casting examinations to E2422. Use the applicable edition and the complete procedure with a qualified inspection team.

Turn a drawing zone into an inspectable requirement

For a machined sealing face, decide whether acceptance is about the finished surface, internal indications, leakage under defined conditions, or a combination. Then record the agreement. If machining opens pores on a finished face, see porosity on machined surfaces for how to accept or disposition them. The fields below are a purchasing aid, not a completed inspection specification.

FieldEntry the project team completes
Part and regionPart number, drawing revision, zone ID and boundaries
Assessed conditionAs-cast, after heat treatment, after machining, or as supplied
DiscontinuityCategory, and any separate criteria for other indications
InspectionProcedure ID, method and coverage
AcceptanceReference, edition and level, or a defined numerical criterion
SamplingLot definition, quantity or frequency, selection
EvidenceImages or measurements, part ID, interpretation record
Failure responseContainment, review authority, disposition

If a numerical criterion is needed, define what is measured. An area fraction on a stated section, a projected indication and a three-dimensional volume fraction are not the same result.

Drawing-note templates

Copy and complete. Brackets are left for the values your design authority sets; we do not fill them in for you.

ZONE A (sealing face, see view B): RADIOGRAPHIC INSPECTION PER [standard, edition]. ACCEPTANCE: [category] LEVEL [ ] MAX, CONDITION [after machining]. SAMPLING: [ ] PCS PER LOT, LOT = [definition].
ZONE B (remainder): [level / not inspected].
LEAK TEST: [method], [medium] AT [pressure, unit], REJECT ABOVE [leak rate, unit], AFTER [stage], [100% / sampling].
IMPREGNATION: [NOT PERMITTED / PERMITTED PER (spec) WITH REINSPECTION].

Specify leak acceptance separately

A radiographic classification is not a leak-test result. For a pressure boundary, agree the leakage requirement and the procedure that demonstrates it alongside any internal-integrity examination: test medium, pressure, part condition, reject threshold and units, timing and the tested boundary. See helium leak testing for the report fields.

Check the system can make the decision

An inspection requirement must be achievable by the chosen system. ASTM E2422 calls for agreement that the system can detect and classify the required discontinuities; ask how that will be shown for your regions, not only the equipment model. Record who interprets results, how uncertain results escalate, and agree a referee procedure before the first disputed delivery.

Connect sample approval to lot release

Keep the qualification package separate from routine lot records. Agree what happens on a failed result: how material is held, who reviews it, whether more examination is allowed and who signs a concession. If impregnation or repair is proposed, treat it as a documented decision with reinspection. A change of alloy, geometry, tooling or route re-opens the approval.

Squeeze casting and porosity

Squeeze casting solidifies under pressure and suppresses shrinkage and gas porosity, but no process guarantees zero porosity. A squeeze-cast part is accepted on the same zone-based criteria as any other casting. The A356-T6 squeeze casting page shows where the process is evaluated; the casting inspection plan holds the checks together.

Questions about porosity acceptance

What porosity is acceptable in a casting?
It depends on the region and its function. Specify zones on the drawing and, per zone, the discontinuity, method, reference standard and level, condition, sampling and failure response. A sealing face and a non-functional boss need different limits.
Which ASTM standard applies to porosity in aluminum castings?
ASTM E155 (film) and E2422 (digital) are reference radiographs for aluminum and magnesium castings; E505 (film) and E2973 (digital) for aluminum and magnesium die castings. They classify indications; you still choose the level.
Is a radiographic level the same as a leak test?
No. Specify leak acceptance separately: medium, pressure, condition, reject threshold with units, timing and tested boundary.

Send the drawing with your porosity zones

Mark the zones, the reference standard and level, and any leak criterion. Howard Ding replies with how we would inspect them.

Send a drawing for DFM review

What happens next

  1. Howard Ding confirms receipt and asks for anything missing from the package.
  2. Engineering reviews geometry, alloy and acceptance criteria and proposes a route: squeeze casting, die casting, or a reason neither fits.
  3. You receive the quotation with tooling, samples and validation listed separately from the part price.